top of page

Performance improvement plans: when to use one and how to get it right

Anne-Marie Dolan
Nov 12
6 min read

When an employee is struggling, it can put pressure on the whole business. Work needs checking, deadlines slip, and other team members may pick up extra tasks.  A performance improvement plan, or PIP, can help you address those problems. But it needs to give the employee a real chance to succeed.  For New Zealand employers, a good PIP sets clear expectations, provides support and creates a fair way to review progress. Here is how to approach it.


PIP. Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch. Ipad with performance plan on it.

What is a PIP, and when should you use one?

A PIP is a written plan for helping an employee bring their work up to the required standard. It explains the concerns, what needs to improve, the support available and when progress will be reviewed.  You might consider one when an employee repeatedly makes errors, misses reasonable deadlines or struggles with core duties despite feedback and help.  Usually, a formal PIP comes after informal steps have failed to resolve the problem. It should not be the first time the employee hears that their work is falling short.


First, identify the right process. Difficulty doing the job may call for performance management. Alleged dishonesty or deliberate rule-breaking may require a misconduct process. Illness or injury may need a different approach again.


What should happen before a PIP?

Before asking an employee to improve, check that your expectations are reasonable.  Review their employment agreement, job description, training and workload. Have you explained the standard? Are they being asked to do work outside their role? Do they have working equipment and enough time?  If the problem comes from poor systems or unclear instructions, address those issues first.


Explain the concerns using examples. “Three customer orders had incorrect delivery details last week” is more useful than “You are careless.”  Ask what is getting in the way. There may be gaps in training, conflicting instructions, bullying, health concerns or personal pressures.


Listen without jumping to conclusions. If health or disability is involved, consider what support or reasonable adjustments may be needed. Get advice before treating those circumstances as ordinary poor performance.


Depending on the issue, you could provide coaching, refresher training, clearer instructions or regular check-ins.  Explain what improvement you need and allow reasonable time for it. Keep brief records of the discussion, support offered and progress.


Check the employment agreement and relevant policies before moving to a formal process. Follow any applicable requirements. Employment New Zealand guidance supports addressing problems early and trying informal measures before formal performance management.


What should a PIP include?

A useful performance improvement plan answers six questions.


1. What is the problem?

Describe specific gaps, supported by dated examples. Keep the language factual and respectful.


2. What standard is required?

Use clear measures linked to the employee’s actual role. Avoid vague goals such as “show more initiative.” For example: “For the next four weekly reports, submit the completed report by 3 pm Friday using the checklist provided.”


3. What actions will help?

Break improvement into practical steps. These might include completing training, using a checking process or confirming priorities with a manager.


4. What will the employer provide?

Name the support, who will provide it and when. “Training available if needed” is less useful than booking a specific training session.


5. When will progress be reviewed?

Set a realistic timeframe, regular review dates and a final review meeting. Allow enough time to learn and demonstrate improvement through normal work.


6. What are the possible outcomes?

Explain how successful completion will be assessed and what may happen if performance remains below standard. Depending on the stage of the process, further action could include warnings and, ultimately, dismissal following a fair process.


Employment New Zealand describes a PIP as a tool for constructive discussion, practical improvement steps, training and realistic timeframes. 

 

What should you leave out?

Do not overload the plan with every frustration you have ever had.


Avoid personal labels such as “lazy” or “bad attitude”; targets the employee cannot control; unrealistic deadlines or standards; unrelated historical complaints; and new duties disguised as performance expectations.  It is important that the PIP does not suggest the employee stops raising legitimate concerns or any statements suggesting dismissal has already been decided.


For example, a sales employee can control whether they follow up leads. They cannot fully control whether customers buy. Consider both activity and results when setting fair measures.


Do not use a PIP to push someone out, avoid a redundancy process or punish a complaint. The plan must offer a genuine opportunity to improve.


How do you introduce a PIP?

Invite the employee to a private meeting in writing. Explain the concerns and that you are considering a formal PIP.  Provide the relevant examples and draft plan beforehand, with reasonable time to prepare. Explain any possible consequences and let the employee know they can bring a representative or support person.


At the meeting, explain the purpose calmly:

“We have discussed the reporting errors and provided extra training, but the required improvement has not yet happened. We are proposing a formal plan to make the expectations and support clear. We want your feedback before we finalise it.”


Work through the draft together. Ask whether the targets are clear, whether the timeframe is workable and whether other support is needed.  Consider the employee’s response with an open mind. Change the proposal where appropriate, then confirm the final plan and reasons in writing.  Ask the employee to acknowledge receipt. Their signature does not need to mean agreement with every concern. If they decline to sign, record that and address their objections fairly.


What happens while the PIP is in place?

A PIP needs active management. Sending the document and waiting until the end is not enough.  

Hold the scheduled check-ins. Discuss each target, review examples and give prompt feedback. Recognise progress as well as ongoing gaps.

  

Deliver the support you promised. If training is cancelled or equipment fails, consider how that affects the employee’s opportunity to improve.


Keep written notes and share them so the employee can identify errors or add comments. Record evidence against the measures, rather than relying on general impressions.


Avoid shifting the goalposts. If a new concern arises, explain it and give the employee a fair opportunity to respond. Do not quietly add it to the final assessment.


Review timing if circumstances change. Significant leave, missing support or too few opportunities to practise may justify adjusting the review period.


How should you conclude a PIP?

Meet with the employee, review the evidence and hear their response before deciding the outcome.  


If the employee meets the requirements

Confirm successful completion in writing. Acknowledge the improvement and explain that the required standards continue as part of their normal role. 


Return to ordinary supervision and feedback. A few planned follow-ups can help maintain progress, but avoid leaving someone on a formal PIP indefinitely.


If the employee makes some progress

Consider how much improvement has occurred, what remains and why.

An extension may be reasonable where progress is meaningful or the employee has not had a fair chance to demonstrate improvement. Set a clear end date and explain the remaining targets and support.


An extension should have a purpose. Repeatedly restarting the same plan without addressing the barriers is unlikely to help.


If the employee does not meet the requirements

Check whether the targets were fair, support was delivered and the assessment is supported by evidence. Consider the employee’s explanation.


Further action may be appropriate, including a warning or final warning, depending on the process so far. Before issuing one, explain the proposed action and reasons, allow a response and genuinely consider it.


If dismissal is being considered, seek advice before proceeding. Share the proposed reasons and relevant information, give a reasonable opportunity to respond and consider that response before making a final decision.


A failed PIP does not automatically justify dismissal. Employment New Zealand says employers must have tried to resolve poor performance through a performance management process first.


FAQs

How long should a PIP last?

There is no fixed period that suits every role. Choose a timeframe that gives a reasonable opportunity to improve, considering the tasks, training and frequency of the work being assessed.


Is a PIP the same as a warning?

No. A PIP sets out the improvement process. A warning formally identifies an unacceptable standard and the consequences of failing to improve. Be clear about whether a separate warning has been issued.


What if the employee disagrees with the PIP?

Listen, check their concerns and correct anything unfair or inaccurate. Disagreement does not automatically prevent a reasonable plan from proceeding, but you must consider their feedback.


Can I dismiss someone as soon as the PIP ends?

Not automatically. The expiry date triggers a review. Any dismissal needs a justified reason and fair process, taking account of warnings, support, progress and the employee’s response.


Performance concerns can be difficult to handle when you are also running a business.  Employer Direct can help you assess the issue, prepare a practical PIP and manage meetings and next steps. Getting advice early can help you support your employee while setting clear standards for your business.



Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. While we strive to keep the information accurate and up to date, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the blog or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the blog for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. For specific legal advice tailored to your situation, please contact a qualified legal professional. 

Comments


bottom of page